It’s still much too early to install the April patches. Details coming in Computerworld Woody on Windows. I’m moving us down to MS-DEFCON 2: Patch rel
[See the full post at: MS-DEFCON 2: Patching conflicts with Sophos and Avast are getting better, but Avira’s a no-show. Don’t patch.]
|
Patch reliability is unclear, but widespread attacks make patching prudent. Go ahead and patch, but watch out for potential problems. |
-
MS-DEFCON 2: Patching conflicts with Sophos and Avast are getting better, but Avira’s a no-show. Don’t patch.
- This topic has 55 replies, 17 voices, and was last updated 6 years ago.
AuthorViewing 19 reply threadsAuthor-
Encouraged by comments from a fellow Panda AV user on one of the earlier threads about the April 2019 updates, after making system partition backups for W7 Home Premium and W8.1 Pro (dual-booting) for both 32 bit and 64 bit PCs I took the plunge and updated with the Security Only (SO) and IE updates from the Windows Catalog.
For W7 I have Panda AV running in parallel with Malwarebytes Antimalware Premium and everything looks OK after the updates. As noted in the earlier thread there was a 2nd reboot for the SO update (at the login window after the 1st reboot).
For W8.1 I only have Panda AV and again everything looks OK. The occasional Windows Explorer problem which re-appears every few months with a windows update did not re-appear this month. There was only 1 reboot with the SO update. The IE updating did take a long time to get started (delayed at the “searching for updates …” stage), but completed eventually.
BTW: I had been a satisfied Avira user for many years until a couple of years ago when I found it was then making my old PCs very slow. I tried rebuilding the PC s/w again from scratch, but it was still slow. I was also annoyed by their “Launcher/Connect” adware thing which they kept forcibly installing although I tried to uninstall it – malware behaviour itself.
HTH. Garbo.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
If this is only affecting some makers’ security software then maybe it’s safer to wait and see but I have applied the patches to my HP probook(Windows 7 Pro laptop) and I have always used the security only patches since MS started its cumulative/all in one style patching in Oct 2016.
I’m running Norton Security Suite(ISP’s version provided to customers as part of service) and have had no issues after the updates where installed. I’ll wait longer for my other laptops to apply the updates but I have not read about any other non Security Software related issues with MS’s April 2019 patches on windows 7.
Maybe Microsoft and the Security Software Folks need to get on the same page regarding security patches and testing for any Security Software issues with any MS OS/API or application patching. The Security Software folks make use of many OS Kernel/API hooks and maybe they should have some representatives that are stationed at MS’s patching division headquarters(if there still is a Patching and/or Q/A and Q/C headquarters) to see that their respective Security Suites have no issues.
Making use of any Undocumented OS/Kernel/API hooks appears to be an ongoing issue with Security Software so maybe that process needs to change in the future. But Microsoft needs to make sure that it maitains some Proper and Well Documented/Well Maintained OS/Kernel/API hooks for the third party security software providors to access and properly protect the consumer’s PCs/Laptops that make use of MS’s various OS/API ecosystems.
-
hi woody.
do you believe this new article from Softpedia news about the KB4493509 update?
seems that ArcaBit has released a software update for their antivirus software that now works with the KB4493509 update for Win10 1809.
and remember that article by Avira titled “Why does my system run very slow”? Avira seems to have recently pulled that KB article as it now produces a 404 not found error message.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
There are those who blame the AVs for the problems that occurred. And I have to say that the use of illegal APIs and hooks into the kernel should not be excused.
But we are talking about several major AVs here, on millions of PCs everywhere. Microsoft does not give the AV manufacturers access to Windows patches ahead of time. So they have no way to test what is coming.
But Microsoft most certainly has access to the major AVs programs. All the time. And they have the ability to block them from the updates. In fact, they did so after the fact. It wasn’t only consumers that were effected as many businesses felt the impact as well.
There is no excuse for Microsoft allowing a major problem like this to occur – unless they are just plain negligent or just don’t care about their customers (or maybe both).
10 users thanked author for this post.
-
There are those who blame the AVs for the problems that occurred. And I have to say that the use of illegal APIs and hooks into the kernel should not be excused. But we are talking about several major AVs here, on millions of PCs everywhere. Microsoft does not give the AV manufacturers access to Windows patches ahead of time. So they have no way to test what is coming. But Microsoft most certainly has access to the major AVs programs. All the time. And they have the ability to block them from the updates. In fact, they did so after the fact. It wasn’t only consumers that were effected as many businesses felt the impact as well. There is no excuse for Microsoft allowing a major problem like this to occur – unless they are just plain negligent or just don’t care about their customers (or maybe both).
Is it Microsoft’s job to look for compatibility issues for all software or just AV products? Adobe refused to support Lightroom on Windows 8.1 after a dll fix on a Microsoft update caused issues. I was forced to update to Windows 10 because that’s what Adobe supports these days. I’m sympathetic to users who ran into problems with the patches but I’m not sure that Microsoft is wholly to blame here.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
-
The Previews contain only the non-security updates for the upcoming Rollup. Since this problem also affected the upcoming Security-only updates (upcoming security patches are not included in the Previews), the use of the Previews would not have shown the problems. The AVs did not have access to the patches ahead of time.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
I personally just have a problem with any features breaking during extended support. One of the main reasons to stick with extended support versions is to avoid the churn that happens with the constant updates.
The reason I’m on Windows 7 is to avoid the problems they have with a constantly changing codebase that needs semiannual replacements just to function. I would have been on Windows 10 if they had just had incremental updates the whole time that did not constantly have issues. They could have done less work and had more uptake.
1 user thanked author for this post.
https://answers.avira.com/en/question/explorer-freeze-during-update-win10-82695
two program version updates from Avira such as 15.0.45.1154 & 15.0.45.1165 and still these new versions don’t play well with the KB4493509 update from MS.
either uninstall the KB4493509 update OR uninstall the Avira antivirus program entirely and use another AV program that works with KB4493509
seems like MS has to fix their own code with a newer CU for win10 v1809
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
https://answers.avira.com/en/question/explorer-freeze-during-update-win10-82695
two program version updates from Avira such as 15.0.45.1154 & 15.0.45.1165 and still these new versions don’t play well with the KB4493509 update from MS.
either uninstall the KB4493509 update OR uninstall the Avira antivirus program entirely and use another AV program that works with KB4493509
seems like MS has to fix their own code with a newer CU for win10 v1809
But the person who started that thread said they don’t have that MS update installed and their problems with Avira updates started seven weeks earlier.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
and remember that article by Avira titled “Why does my system run very slow”? Avira seems to have recently pulled that KB article as it now produces a 404 not found error message.
The article has been deleted – now only am empty site with ‘was this article helpful’ is displayed. But I received a comment from an AVIRA user to an article I wrote yesterday about the topic in German news site Heise. The reader claims, that his issues are gonce since hours, although Avira and the update are still installed in Windows 7. He suppose a ‘secret Avira update’ – and another user confirmed that. I’ve compiled more details within my blog post Windows patchday issues–one week later (April 17, 2019)
Ex Microsoft Windows (Insider) MVP, Microsoft Answers Community Moderator, Blogger, Book author
https://www.borncity.com/win/
-
-
The Preview is a non-security patch. It does NOT contain the next month’s security Updates.
Since this affected both the next month’s Rollup AND Security-only patches, the problem was in the SECURITY part of the update and would thus NOT be in the Preview.
The AVs would NOT have had access.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
-
-
-
The question wasn’t whether I would want the AVs to have access or not.
The question was who COULD have tested ahead of time to recognize/prevent the problem that was caused. My contention is, that Microsoft COULD have realized the outcome (and who knows, they may have) and prevented the havoc, but the AVs could not.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
The problem with outside vendor anti-virus software suggests that in the future, only Microsoft software and Microsoft officially-supported software will run without error.
On permanent hiatus {with backup and coffee}
offline▸ Win10Pro 2004.19041.572 x64 i3-3220 RAM8GB HDD Firefox83.0b3 WindowsDefender
offline▸ Acer TravelMate P215-52 RAM8GB Win11Pro 22H2.22621.1265 x64 i5-10210U SSD Firefox106.0 MicrosoftDefender
online▸ Win11Pro 22H2.22621.1992 x64 i5-9400 RAM16GB HDD Firefox116.0b3 MicrosoftDefenderditch Avira!
they have released 3 program updates so far (15.0.45.1154, 15.0.45.1165 & 15.0.45.1171) and still these Avira updates don’t fix the slowdowns with the KB4493509 update for win10 v1809
some users here have already jumped ship and decided to use another AV:
https://answers.avira.com/en/question/two-updates-later-and-avira-still-causing-major-win10-issues-827061 user thanked author for this post.
-
We are at DEFCON-2 (to see a description of the DEFCON system, click on the button in the top gray menubar).
The answer to your question, in a word: NO.
On the page you linked, these are the known issues. The one with McAfee just showed up yesterday.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Haven’t posted in awhile, is it just my imagination, or has the tone here deteriorated a bit?
Just stopped by to observe that a cynical interpretation of M$’s cascading update catastrophes would call them part of a deliberate strategy to fatally wound Win7 & 8.1 to the point they become unusable, and the holdouts (like me & my Win7) have no choice left but to move to Win10. I haven’t signed on to that opinion yet, but I am inching ever closer. My decision to jump from Group B to Group W as of Dec 2017 is looking better with every passing month – and no, I have experienced NO adverse incidents as a result.
I had been thinking, though, that it might be a good idea to consult Woody (and The Lounge) for ideas about a possible exit strategy when Win7 support ends:
- can we expect final, clean updates for all functions of Win7 on Jan 15, 2020?
- if so, should I consider updating my OS accordingly at that time?
- or am I better off just staying put?
I had been leaning toward #2, but now I’m not sure, now the adage “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” has a certain appeal. Woody, I hope you plan to address this matter in future columns, and I’m sure I’m not alone.
In the meantime, Woody, I got ambushed on my way here today, from a COMPLETELY unexpected quarter: when I clicked on the AskWoody link at the bottom of your column (and got the same result with my own archived link) it threw a Wordfence/Wordpress block on access! I have no idea what those are, so the solutions offered were nonsensical!
After I wasted time restarting FF with add-ons disabled, then turned off Zone Alarm Free FW, I finally found the culprit: the block was triggered by the alias IP I was connected to on NordVPN!
-
I’m still patching Group A using @abbodi86 ‘s method (AKB2000012) to limit telemetry. Figure I’l get as patched as I can before there are no more patches. After that….
Try this link about proxies and VPNs.
Speaking of IP addresses, you might also try:
WhatsMyIPAddress and CleanTalk.orgIt’s an eye-opener.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
-
Check with CustomerSupport@AskWoody.com about the Plus membership (Gold badge).
That’s Woody on the other end of that email address.3 users thanked author for this post.
-
-
-
Hello @Northwest Rick,
As someone who also joined Group W since December 2017 (to avoid the Specter/Meltdown patches) I’m facing the same future/decisions as you are.
I think the change of tone is less a deterioration, than integration of the Windows Secrets folks. Group B/W choices are alien to them, as well as the discussions we had that led to those choices. There have always been those who have had strong opinions… (yes, I’m looking in a mirror and see one opinionated grandma!), and the Windows Secrets folks aren’t any different.
The challenge is to be able to express diverse opinions without disrespecting each other, explaining options, and encouraging and supporting others to make their own educated decisions, even as Microsoft has been discouraging and limiting and engaging in marketing babble speak, to push everyone to do it their way.
Those of us, especially those that are technically challenged (like me), who are rejecting the privacy invasions on personal ethics and moral grounds, can be at a disadvantage on a tech site. However, it is just as important that large corporations act in ethical ways. Evaluating the usefulness of their products regarding personal end users’ needs is as valid, if not more so, than how well the code and features work (especially when they are deliberately masking and minimizing the impact of data harvesting). Too many techies get caught up in the marketing speak, and believe it is for their own good, and the good of everyone else, and accept turning customers into products, rather than really exploring the social and ethical implications. Actually, too many people get caught up in the specific language of their various fields and tend to ignore how they integrate or interact with others… which does lead to the feelings and needs of non-technical users being dismissed and ignored here as well. It isn’t as if the lack of privacy isn’t going to affect technical users, but their focus doesn’t tend to be on themselves and community as much as the hardware and software specifics. There are some enlightened folk who do not dismiss the right and need for privacy, and seek to use technology to inform others of their choices, or develop ways to allow such choices… but too often, you hear the voices of those who still believe that greater privacy invasion is somehow more secure… and that Microsoft actually could not develop its AI while respecting our privacy… and that is much more important that Microsoft’s goals be supported, and that sacrificing home users is of little to no significance in service of those goals…
There are cultural differences, everywhere we look in the world. For me, it will never be acceptable to use others irrespective of their own needs… that is predatory and self-serving. Because of recognizing that Microsoft is intentionally doing so, Microsoft, as a business, is not one I will support further. However, there are a lot of good things worth salvaging… and fairly few people are willing to call Microsoft on the carpet for saying they give end users a choice, but fail to provide an off button to telemetry. Microsoft is hoping that people will be satisfied by the features, and not notice the reaping of their information. They cover themselves legally… but we still have choices. My choice is not to go further down their W10 service instead of an operating system road.
Woody has set up a Windows 7 Group A machine, specifically for testing and seeing how Microsoft treats the end users unwilling to upgrade. But it is @Canadian Tech who led the way to setting up our Windows 7 without telemetry, and providing tech support so that others could do the same. I haven’t heard of anyone who followed his advice to have had any loss of usefulness of their computers, or being subject to malware problems… and all of us have avoided the continuing drama and stress of Microsoft updating.
At the same time, the DEFCON system is exceedingly useful for those who make different decisions under the same circumstances, allowing them to minimize the adverse impact of having been relegated to beta testing patches. It is as important to respect their decisions, as it is for them to respect ours.
Can’t help but savor the stability, reliability, and usefulness of the choice I’ve made, and sometimes feel gleeful when the bug reports are flooding in… but I know I’ll have to continue to make choices in the future… and it is important to have accurate reports on W10’s performance and features to guide my decision making.
Don’t feel lost in the big splash that ‘merging the whale’ floods us with… stepping up and posting will help inform others of their ability to make other choices… and reports of the stability and lack of problems will stand in stark contrast to the bugs, BSOD, and lack of choice that W10 users are constantly faced with.
Every month I try to understand, not just note, the bugs that come up, for all the operating systems. I look for patterns, for root causes, for usefulness, for what is spoken of and what is ignored. The more that technology is being integrated into our daily lives, the more important our choices become.
It surely puzzles me, though, that a company like Microsoft would choose to abuse end users, people who have invested in their products, and rationalize how it is okay. That, alone, is a symptom of how far off track they are.
It further puzzles me, that even though people have struggled for rights and freedom throughout the world for centuries, and been willing to sacrifice their lives to such end, that so many people would ignore the violations of hard won rights, just to be able to use the latest tech… and pay for the privilege.
Non-techy Win 10 Pro and Linux Mint experimenter
the plot thickens again woody
looks like Avira has re-posted that missing KB article “Why does my system run very slow?” late TH April 18:
https://answers.avira.com/en/question/why-does-my-system-run-very-slow-82653Avira claims the slowdown issues are fixed with the recent 15.0.45.1171 update but some of the users there in that KB article are saying otherwise
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Avira will feature prominently in my lead article in Monday morning’s AskWoody Plus Newsletter.
It’s weird, though. They and now McAfee are the only ones who are pointing a finger at this month’s Win10 1809 cumulative update.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
My view varies to yours.
– Too many seem to be bashing Microsoft to fit it.
– We don’t need Microsoft getting away with evil deeds but we do need to hold back until there is sufficient evidence what they are doing. For example the idea that Microsoft is deliberately breaking Windows 7 to get people onto Windows 10 is ludicrous.The example doesn’t absolve Microsoft for their updates breaking systems. It simply recognises we should not be stating without evidence the breaks are deliberate. Be angry about the bad deed, not about imagined intent.
-
reading new comments from Avira’s KB article “Why does my system run very slow?”
https://answers.avira.com/en/question/why-does-my-system-run-very-slow-82653seems like Avira got it right the 4th time with software update version 15.0.45.1184 as this new version no longer has the slowdown problems with the April 2019 updates
took ’em long enough 🙂
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
The DEFCON System refers to PATCHING, not a specific version of Windows. It applies to ALL versions of Windows. (And you should make it a habit for any version of software too, unless you like being a Guinea Pig or cannon fodder)
Read about the MS-DEFCON System here. (button in the top gray menubar)
1 user thanked author for this post.
Viewing 19 reply threads
Plus Membership
Donations from Plus members keep this site going. You can identify the people who support AskWoody by the Plus badge on their avatars.
AskWoody Plus members not only get access to all of the contents of this site -- including Susan Bradley's frequently updated Patch Watch listing -- they also receive weekly AskWoody Plus Newsletters (formerly Windows Secrets Newsletter) and AskWoody Plus Alerts, emails when there are important breaking developments.
Get Plus!
Recent Topics
-
Updates seem to have broken Microsoft Edge
by 1 hour, 21 minutes ago
-
Wait command?
by 30 minutes ago
-
Malwarebytes 5 Free version manual platform updates
by 4 hours, 16 minutes ago
-
inetpub : Microsoft’s patch for CVE-2025–21204 introduces vulnerability
by 10 hours, 52 minutes ago
-
Windows 10 finally gets fix
by 19 hours, 45 minutes ago
-
AMD Ryzen™ Chipset Driver Release Notes 7.04.09.545
by 21 hours, 5 minutes ago
-
Win 7 MS Essentials suddenly not showing number of items scanned.
by 15 hours, 38 minutes ago
-
France : A law requiring messaging apps to implement a backdoor ..
by 1 day, 10 hours ago
-
Dev runs Windows 11 ARM on an iPad Air M2
by 1 day, 10 hours ago
-
MS-DEFCON 3: Cleanup time
by 5 hours, 58 minutes ago
-
KB5056686 (.NET v8.0.15) Delivered Twice in April 2025
by 2 hours, 39 minutes ago
-
How to enable Extended Security Maintenance on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS before it dies
by 1 day, 22 hours ago
-
Windows 11 Insider Preview build 26200.5562 released to DEV
by 2 days, 2 hours ago
-
Windows 11 Insider Preview build 26120.3872 (24H2) released to BETA
by 2 days, 2 hours ago
-
Unable to eject external hard drives
by 12 hours, 42 minutes ago
-
Saying goodbye to not-so-great technology
by 23 minutes ago
-
Tech I don’t miss, and some I do
by 6 hours, 16 minutes ago
-
Synology limits hard drives
by 3 days, 6 hours ago
-
Links from Microsoft 365 and from WhatsApp not working
by 2 days, 8 hours ago
-
WhatsApp Security Advisories CVE-2025-30401
by 3 days, 12 hours ago
-
Upgrade Sequence
by 3 days, 5 hours ago
-
Chrome extensions with 6 million installs have hidden tracking code
by 1 day, 11 hours ago
-
Uninstall “New Outlook” before installing 2024 Home & Business?
by 2 days, 4 hours ago
-
The incredible shrinking desktop icons
by 4 days, 9 hours ago
-
Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 22635.5240 (23H2) released to BETA
by 4 days, 11 hours ago
-
Connecting hard drive on USB 3.2 freezes File Explorer & Disk Management
by 1 day, 10 hours ago
-
Shellbag Analyser & Cleaner Update
by 1 day, 3 hours ago
-
CISA warns of increased breach risks following Oracle Cloud leak
by 4 days, 20 hours ago
-
Outlook 2024 two sent from email addresses
by 6 hours, 5 minutes ago
-
Speeding up 11’s search
by 2 days, 8 hours ago
Remembering Woody
